The 3 Best Consignment Stores Around Utah County

Hunting for high-quality fashion on a budget has become its own sport in Utah Valley, with consignment sales growing 14 percent last year as shoppers seek sustainable style (ThredUp Resale Report, 2024). From curated designer finds to everyday wardrobe staples, the finalists for Best Consignment Store blend affordability with fresh rotating inventory—so you can refresh your closet without breaking the bank.

My Sister’s Closet Boutique

My Sister’s Closet Boutique showcases gently worn women’s apparel and accessories, hand-selected for quality and style. The Spanish Fork storefront features seasonal collections of denim, dresses and handbags—many from contemporary brands like Free People and Madewell. Each piece undergoes a meticulous inspection for wear, ensuring shoppers walk away with nearly-new items at a fraction of retail cost. Regular “Ladies’ Night” events pair champagne with personal styling sessions, adding a social twist to thrifting.

Renewed Vintage Market

Renewed Vintage Market doubles as a consignment hub and multi-vendor marketplace. With more than 30 vendors offering clothing, jewelry and home décor, the American Fork shop refreshes its racks weekly. Shoppers praise the mix of vintage Levi’s, artisan-made scarves and retro graphic tees. Limited-time pop-ups—often featuring local designers—give customers a reason to return and discover fresh finds on each visit.

Preloved

Preloved in Spanish Fork specializes in affordable consignments for the entire family. Browse racks of children’s outfits alongside women’s business casual and men’s weekend wear. The store’s easy-consign program guarantees sellers get paid within days of a sale, and shoppers benefit from clear size tags and organized sections. Monthly “Flash Sale” promotions clear last season’s stock, offering steep discounts and making room for new arrivals.

Thanks, ChatGPT.